Why You Don’t Need $1 Million to Retire Comfortably: Expert Reveals Shocking Truth!

You've probably heard the advice: to retire comfortably, you need a million dollars in the bank. Investment firms, financial planners, and news headlines often tout this figure as the gold standard for retirement savings.

But is it truly necessary? Andrew Biggs, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, argues otherwise. According to him, you can retire comfortably with much less—between $50,000 and $100,000 in total savings. Let’s dive into why Biggs believes the million-dollar retirement goal is vastly overstated.

Debunking the Million-Dollar Myth

Most Americans don’t have anywhere near a million dollars saved for retirement. This lofty figure often comes from opinion polls, financial advice columns, and a few prevalent rules of thumb within the financial planning industry. For example, many financial advisors suggest saving ten times your annual salary, which would allow you to live on 4% of your savings each year.

However, according to Biggs, these recommendations don’t align with the reality of most retirees' experiences. He points to data from the federal Survey of Household Economics and Decision-making (SHED) from 2019 to 2022, which shows that a majority of retirement-age Americans (65 to 74) are managing quite well financially without huge savings.

Living Comfortably Without Millions

Biggs's analysis of the SHED data revealed that roughly 85% of retirees reported that they were living comfortably or at least "doing OK." Only 15% indicated they were struggling. This is significant because most of these retirees have much less than $1 million in the bank. In fact, the typical senior who reported a satisfactory retirement had between $50,000 and $100,000 in savings.

Biggs emphasizes, "It’s impossible to find any evidence that seniors need even a fraction of $1.46 million in savings to be financially secure." His argument suggests that the financial planning industry may overstate the required retirement savings to drum up business.

The Role of Social Security

A significant portion of retirees’ income comes from Social Security benefits. According to Biggs, the average couple who retired in 2022 received nearly $46,000 annually from Social Security. While not extravagant, this amount is more than twice the elderly poverty threshold before tapping into personal savings.

This reality counters the narrative pushed by some financial planners who claim retirees need to rely heavily on their savings. In fact, many retirees manage quite well on their Social Security benefits, supplemented by relatively modest personal savings.

Questioning Conventional Wisdom

Biggs’s assertion that you don’t need a million dollars to retire comfortably has sparked a range of reactions. Some readers praised his perspective, while others criticized it. One detractor quipped, “You don’t need to be a millionaire to retire and do NOTHING!!!”

Despite the controversy, Biggs's views challenge the status quo of retirement planning. For instance, Lili Vasileff, a certified financial planner, raises concerns about rising healthcare costs, older adult children living with parents, and late-life divorces that can split retirement assets. These factors can indeed strain retirement finances, but they don’t necessarily mandate a million-dollar nest egg.

Understanding Retirement Savings

The 2022 Survey of Consumer Finances indicates that the typical senior with a retirement account has about $200,000 saved. However, only about half of these households report having retirement accounts at all. Biggs argues that many retirees also have other forms of savings and pensions that aren’t always accounted for in such surveys.

Alicia Munnell, director of the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College, estimates that at least two-fifths of retirees are struggling financially. When asked about handling a financial emergency, only 58% of seniors said they could rely on savings, reflecting underlying financial insecurity.

Pride and Financial Well-being

Why do only 15% of seniors admit to struggling financially in surveys, as Biggs points out? Munnell suggests that retirees may be reluctant to discuss financial difficulties due to pride. “When people are asked about their well-being, I think there’s a certain pride. You don’t want to say, ‘I really screwed up,’” she says.

Despite differing views on the financial well-being of retirees, both Biggs and Munnell agree that setting unrealistic savings goals can be discouraging. Most people do not retire as millionaires, and holding such an expectation can lead to frustration and anxiety.

Word From Our Sponsor

Ready to unlock the secrets of maximizing your travel rewards? Sign up for the Better Than Points newsletter and discover how to turn your credit card points into unforgettable travel experiences.

From expert tips on earning and redeeming points to exclusive insights on the best travel deals, this Better Than Points newsletter is your ultimate guide to savvy travel hacking. Don’t miss out on the chance to travel smarter and stretch your points further.

Realistic Retirement Savings

Financial experts often recommend saving enough to cover 80% of your preretirement income. Social Security typically covers about half of this amount, leaving the rest to be supplemented by personal savings. For a typical American household, this translates to nearly $750,000 in savings, assuming you follow the guideline of saving ten times your annual salary.

The 4% rule is another common guideline: plan to withdraw 4% of your retirement savings annually to cover living expenses, adjusting for inflation each year. While this rule provides a starting point, it’s not one-size-fits-all. Individual needs vary based on lifestyle, health, and other personal factors.

Changing Spending Patterns in Retirement

Biggs argues that retirees generally spend less as they age. Expenses like travel, dining out, and supporting children tend to decrease, even as healthcare costs rise. Most medical expenses are covered by insurance, reducing the financial burden on retirees.

“Retirees reduce their spending pretty significantly as they age,” Biggs notes. This shift in spending patterns suggests that the 4% withdrawal rule might be more flexible than initially thought.

Conclusion: Setting Realistic Goals

The idea that you need $1 million to retire comfortably is more myth than reality for many Americans. By examining actual retirement experiences and considering income from Social Security, it becomes clear that a comfortable retirement is achievable with much less savings. Instead of being disheartened by unattainable goals, focus on realistic financial planning that aligns with your personal circumstances.

FAQs

1. How much money do I really need to retire comfortably?

You don’t necessarily need $1 million. Many retirees manage well with $50,000 to $100,000 in savings, supplemented by Social Security benefits.

2. Why do financial planners recommend saving so much for retirement?

Financial planners often set high savings goals to ensure clients are well-prepared for retirement. However, these goals can sometimes be unrealistic and discouraging.

3. Can I rely on Social Security for most of my retirement income?

While Social Security can cover a significant portion of your retirement income, it’s wise to have additional savings to maintain your lifestyle and cover unexpected expenses.

4. How does spending change as I age in retirement?

Retirees typically spend less on travel, dining out, and supporting children as they age, though healthcare costs may rise. Insurance often covers most medical expenses.

5. Is it possible to retire comfortably without a retirement account?

Yes, many retirees rely on a combination of Social Security, other savings, and pensions. The key is to plan according to your specific financial situation and goals.